Let's Dive Deep into the Tagging Debate in Writing Communities
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding the Tagging Phenomenon
The topic of tagging has been on my mind for quite some time, and recent discussions have prompted me to share my thoughts on it.
Do you enjoy being tagged? Personally, I find it quite beneficial. As a relatively new writer in this community, being tagged gives me a sense of belonging (perhaps I’m a bit needy?). It keeps me informed about various discussions that I might otherwise overlook, and I’m eager to assist others in expanding their readership and fostering community connections. After all, building a community and encouraging member engagement is crucial for success here.
When a writer tags you in their work, it can also open doors to new connections — I’ve discovered some remarkable individuals this way.
Tagging can serve the purpose of uniting groups of writers, as seen with the Salt Path reading group organized by Scot Butwell, or the Read for Read Club run by Indigo, and even Andrei Alin's New Writer’s Bootcamp. These are all valid reasons for tagging.
Moreover, editors sometimes recommend that writers tag a few peers who contribute to their publication. This strategy effectively boosts engagement. One of my favorite Medium writers, Warren Patterson (who seems to have gone quiet — any updates?), encouraged me to do this when I began writing for Globetrotters, resulting in some meaningful connections.
On the flip side, when I'm not tagged, I can’t help but feel a little hurt. Does that mean we’re no longer friends? Have I done something wrong? I prefer clear communication over guessing games; I’m not a mind reader.
However, I understand that some people dislike tagging. I've seen writers request others to stop bulk tagging, equating it to chain letters, and even witnessed harsh criticisms in comments regarding tagging.
Then there are those passive-aggressive remarks like, “I don’t appreciate being tagged,” which imply displeasure without directly stating it. Being Canadian, I can recognize passive-aggressive behavior when I see it!
If you’re a big-name writer like Tim Denning, you might be too busy to engage with tagging. That’s perfectly fine; simply ignore it. Still, tagging remains a valid and effective approach that benefits many writers. So, I’d advise against dictating what others can or cannot do. Remember, we all started somewhere and likely engaged in tagging ourselves!
While I might sound a bit frustrated, I’m genuinely curious.
What are your thoughts on tagging? Do you want to be tagged, or would you rather not? Please share your views. I’m conducting a bulk tag of several followers here — something I rarely do — but I’m eager to hear your thoughts. Consider this a form of customer service. If you haven’t been tagged, I’d like to know how you feel about it too.
Section 1.1: The Benefits of Tagging
Tagging can enhance visibility and foster connections. It allows writers to discover one another and builds a sense of community.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Role of Editors in Tagging
Editors often encourage tagging to enhance engagement within publications. This strategy can lead to more meaningful interactions among writers.
Section 1.2: The Downside of Tagging
Despite its benefits, not everyone appreciates tagging. Some writers express frustration with excessive tagging, leading to divisive opinions.
Chapter 2: Engaging with the Community
As we explore this topic further, let’s consider how we can engage effectively with our writing communities.
The first video, "Truck Time Returns: Welcome New Fans & Let's Talk Tagging!" discusses the importance of tagging in building a community and connecting with readers.
The second video, "Let's Talk Ranking Updates," dives into the dynamics of engagement and its impact on visibility for writers.